For a UK agency, hiring an SEO executive is cheaper than outsourcing only when you can keep that person on billable client work for roughly 100 hours a month, every month. At the current £35,000 median salary, the 2026/27 employment cost is about £40,400 a year, which works out at about £33 per billable hour if the hours are there and much more if they are not.
Most pages ranking for "outsource SEO vs hire" in the UK compare an agency with an in house SEO from the point of view of a business buying SEO. This guide is for the other side of that table: the agency that sells SEO and has to decide whether to employ the person who does the work or use a partner. Two of the three ranking pages that calculate National Insurance still use the old 13.8% rate, and none turns salary into billable hours or mentions the Employment Allowance or the 2027 change to unfair dismissal rules.
A disclosure before the maths. SMS iT World is a six person delivery team in Chattogram, Bangladesh, and we are one of the options this article compares: an outside partner with no UK office. So we have kept every number sourced and shown the case where hiring is the better choice. If you have already decided to outsource, our guide to white label SEO for UK agencies covers VAT, UK GDPR and contracts in detail.
Should a UK agency outsource SEO or hire an SEO executive?
A UK agency should hire an SEO executive when it has steady, billable SEO work of about 100 hours a month and someone senior to review that work. It should outsource SEO when the workload is below about 60 hours a month, swings with client churn, or needs skills one person cannot cover, such as technical, content and local SEO together.
Between 60 and 100 hours is the grey zone where the answer depends on your margin, your pipeline and who will manage the hire. The rest of this guide gives you the numbers to place your agency on that line instead of guessing.
| Your situation | Better choice | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Fewer than 60 steady billable SEO hours a month | Outsource | A salaried hire would sit partly idle and the cost per used hour climbs above £55 |
| 60 to 100 hours, growing pipeline | Outsource now, plan the hire | Track hours for a quarter before committing to a salary |
| 100+ hours a month for three months running | Hire | The salary is used fully and you keep the margin |
| Work spans technical, content, links and local SEO | Outsource some or all | One executive rarely covers all four at the same standard |
| No senior SEO in the agency to review work | Outsource, or hire senior | A junior hire without review learns on client sites |
| SEO is the agency's core product and brand | Hire, and outsource overflow | You need the expertise inside the business |
What does an SEO executive cost a UK agency in 2026/27?
An SEO executive on the UK median salary of £35,000 costs a UK agency about £40,363 a year in 2026/27 once employer National Insurance (£4,500) and the minimum pension contribution (£862.80) are added. Recruitment adds about £2,000 in the first year, and a seat on an SEO tool adds more. The Employment Allowance can cancel the National Insurance part.
The salary figure comes from ITJobsWatch's SEO Executive tracker: a permanent median of £35,000 for the six months to 11 November 2026, up from £30,000 a year earlier, with a 75th percentile of £41,250. It is based on 25 adverts that quoted a salary, so treat it as a market signal rather than a survey. Outside London the median was £37,500 in the same period.
The on costs below use HMRC's rates and thresholds for employers 2026 to 2027 and The Pensions Regulator's auto enrolment thresholds. Dollar figures use about $1.322 to the pound (13 November 2026); statutory thresholds stay in pounds.
| Cost line | Median hire (£35,000) | Experienced hire (£41,250) | How it is worked out |
|---|---|---|---|
| Salary | £35,000 ($46,270) | £41,250 ($54,533) | ITJobsWatch median and 75th percentile |
| Employer National Insurance | £4,500 ($5,949) | £5,437.50 ($7,188) | 15% of pay above the £5,000 secondary threshold |
| Employer pension (minimum) | £862.80 ($1,141) | £1,050.30 ($1,388) | 3% of qualifying earnings, the band from £6,240 to £50,270 |
| Annual employment cost | £40,362.80 ($53,360) | £47,737.80 ($63,109) | |
| Recruitment, first year only | about £2,000 ($2,644) | about £2,000 ($2,644) | CIPD 2026 median cost per hire, before any recruiter fee |
| SEO tool seat | from $720 a year | from $720 a year | Ahrefs Standard extra user at $60 a month, excluding VAT |
Three details change these numbers for a small agency:
- Employment Allowance. Eligible employers can cut their annual employer National Insurance bill by up to £10,500 in 2026/27. If your agency has not used it up on existing staff, it covers the full £4,500 for a median hire. If you already employ three people on similar pay, it is probably gone.
- The single director rule. A limited company whose only employee is its director cannot claim the Employment Allowance, according to HMRC's National Insurance manual. Hiring one employee paid above the £5,000 threshold can make the company eligible, possibly for the full year. For a one person agency, that is a real saving that the cost tables on other pages ignore.
- The pension is on a band, not the full salary. The 3% applies to qualifying earnings between £6,240 and £50,270, which is why the minimum on £35,000 is £862.80, not £1,050. Many agencies pay more than the minimum, so use your own scheme rate.
What the table leaves out: your own management time, training, a laptop, software licences beyond the SEO tool, and the CIPD caution that its cost per hire figures come from a small subsample. Add those at your own rates.
How many billable hours does one SEO executive give you?
One full time SEO executive on a 37.5 hour week gives a UK agency about 1,740 working hours a year after 28 days of statutory paid leave, and about 1,218 billable hours if 70% of that time goes on client work. That is roughly 100 billable hours a month, at about £33 per billable hour for a median hire.
This is the step the ranking pages skip, and it is the one that matters for an agency, because you sell hours or deliverables, not a salary. Here is the working:
- Contracted hours. 37.5 hours × 52 weeks = 1,950 hours. (Our assumption; use your contract.)
- Holiday. A five day worker is entitled to at least 28 days of paid leave, which can include bank holidays, per GOV.UK's holiday entitlement rules. 28 × 7.5 = 210 hours. That leaves 1,740.
- Billable share. Internal meetings, training, tool admin, sales support and sick days all come out of the remaining time. We use 70% as an example; measure your own team's share for a month before you trust any figure. 1,740 × 70% = 1,218 billable hours, or 101.5 a month.
- Cost per billable hour. £40,362.80 ÷ 1,218 = £33.14 ($43.81) for the median hire, and £39.19 ($51.81) for the £41,250 hire.
Sick leave is also a cost now, not just an absence. Since 6 April 2026, Statutory Sick Pay is due from the first day of illness at £123.25 a week or 80% of average weekly earnings, whichever is lower, because the waiting days and the lower earnings limit were removed.
When does hiring beat outsourcing? The break even test
Hiring beats outsourcing when the cost per hour you actually use falls below what a partner charges for the same output. A salaried executive costs the same whether you have 100 or 40 hours of work, so a median hire costs about £33 per hour when fully used, £56 at 60 used hours a month and £84 at 40.
| Billable SEO hours you can give the hire each month | Cost per used hour, median hire (£40,363) | Cost per used hour, experienced hire (£47,738) |
|---|---|---|
| 101.5 (fully used at 70%) | £33.14 ($43.81) | £39.19 ($51.81) |
| 80 | £42.04 ($55.58) | £49.73 ($65.74) |
| 60 | £56.06 ($74.11) | £66.30 ($87.65) |
| 40 | £84.09 ($111.17) | £99.45 ($131.48) |
To use the table, take your partner's monthly invoice for SEO delivery and divide it by the hours of work it replaces. If the partner prices per deliverable, ask for the hours behind each one, or time one month of the same work yourself. Then compare:
Hire when: partner cost per hour > (annual employment cost ÷ (billable hours you will really use × 12))
Two adjustments keep this honest. First, add your own management hours to the hire, because a new executive needs review, especially in the first months. Second, add your own account management hours to the partner side too: outsourcing removes production work, not client calls. Our guide to white label local SEO shows how to put those hours into the price you charge.
The test also has a time dimension. Workload has to be steady, not an average of a busy spring and a quiet summer. If two clients leaving would drop you from 100 hours to 60, your real cost per hour is the 60 hour figure for as long as it takes to replace them.
What does outsourcing SEO really cost a UK agency?
Outsourcing SEO costs a UK agency the partner's fee plus the agency's own account management time, and for an overseas partner it adds the reverse charge VAT step. There is no employer National Insurance, pension, holiday, sick pay or recruitment cost, and the spend falls when a client leaves, provided the notice terms match your client contracts.
Three UK points change the outsourced figure:
- VAT on an overseas partner's invoice. A VAT registered agency accounts for VAT on services bought from abroad itself under the reverse charge, so it normally nets to zero. An agency that is not VAT registered must add those services to its taxable turnover when checking the £90,000 registration threshold, according to HMRC's place of supply manual. Our UK white label SEO guide has a worked table, including the Flat Rate Scheme trap.
- IR35 if you use a freelancer. If your agency is small (it does not meet two of these for two consecutive years: more than £15 million turnover, more than £7.5 million balance sheet, more than 50 employees), the off payroll rules do not put the status decision on you. A medium or large agency has to issue a status determination for a freelancer working through their own company.
- Notice periods. A partner on 90 days' notice serving clients on 30 days' notice leaves you paying for two months of work you can no longer sell. Match them.
The honest cost of outsourcing is control. You do not choose who works on each client day to day, and quality depends on the partner's process. Test a partner on one paid client before you move more, and keep every login under your own agency's accounts. If you want to run that test with us, start with our white label SEO service for agencies.
How does the Employment Rights Act 2025 change the hiring risk?
The Employment Rights Act 2025 makes a bad hire more expensive to undo from 2027. For dismissals from 1 January 2027, employees gain unfair dismissal protection after six months instead of two years, and the compensatory award cap is removed. A UK agency hiring an SEO executive now must judge fit within that first six months.
The government's implementation timeline, last updated 5 November 2026, lists the changes that affect a small agency's first hire:
| Date | Change | What it means for an SEO hire |
|---|---|---|
| 6 April 2026 | Statutory Sick Pay from day one; lower earnings limit removed | Sick days now cost pay from the first day |
| 6 April 2026 | Paternity leave and unpaid parental leave become day one rights | Plan cover for client work from the start |
| 1 October 2026 | Tribunal claim time limit rises from three to six months | Disputes can surface later after an exit |
| 1 January 2027 | Unfair dismissal after six months' service; compensatory award uncapped | Someone who starts on 1 December 2026 gains protection from around 1 June 2027 |
None of this is a reason not to hire. It is a reason to hire with a written probation plan: named clients, a monthly review of the work against your checklist, and a decision before the six month point. If you cannot commit to that review, the hire is riskier than the cost table suggests. For advice on your own contracts, speak to an employment lawyer; this is a summary, not legal advice.
What do most small UK agencies end up doing?
Most small UK agencies end up with a hybrid: they keep strategy, client communication and final review inside the agency, and outsource production such as audits, on page fixes, citations, content drafts and reporting data. They hire a full time SEO executive later, once the outsourced hours prove there is about 100 hours a month of steady work.
That order has a practical benefit. A partner's monthly invoice and time log become your evidence for the hire: you can see which clients use the most hours, which tasks repeat and which skills you would need in a job description. When you do hire, the executive takes over the repeatable work and the partner keeps the specialist or overflow tasks.
Our advice to agencies in this position: do not hand over the client relationship, even when everything else is outsourced. The person who explains the report and agrees next month's priorities should be someone the client knows at your agency. Our article on the white label SEO report clients actually read splits which parts a partner should prepare and which the agency should write.
Checklist before you post the SEO executive job advert
Before a UK agency posts an SEO executive job advert, it should confirm three months of steady billable SEO hours, its Employment Allowance position, its pension scheme rate, a named reviewer for the new hire, a written probation plan that ends before six months, and an exit plan for any partner work the hire will replace.
- Log billable SEO hours per client for the last three months. Is the average at or near 100 hours a month, and would it survive losing your two largest SEO clients?
- Check with your accountant whether the Employment Allowance is still available this tax year, and whether the single director rule applies to you.
- Price the hire with your own scheme's pension rate and your real tool costs, using the table above.
- Name the senior person who will review the new executive's work every week, and block that time in their diary.
- Write the probation plan: clients, tasks, standards and a decision date before the six month mark.
- Read your partner contract for the notice period, and agree which clients move in house first.
- Move logins, reports and files to agency owned accounts before the transfer, not after.
If the first item fails, outsource for now and come back to this list in a quarter. You can see every guide on this decision in our white label SEO hub.
